I really hate it when companies tell you that open workspaces foster collaboration.  This insults my intelligence, even more than saying that employee satisfaction is a high priority in the Information Technology field.  It’s not.  Stop telling us a 3×3 ft. cube is better than a 4×6 ft. cube because you are closer to your colleagues and can see EVERYTHING now.  It isn’t.  Open workspaces foster nothing except higher employee density per square foot, lower costs, noise, and distraction.  More lipstick on this pig will not make it less of a pig.

I would feel better if they just came out and told us the truth: open workspaces are cheaper!  I’m not dumb, I can tell why the company is buying smaller cubicle walls.  It’s cheaper!  I can tell why they are packing us in like sardines.  More employees in the same space!  (Cheaper!)  Don’t tell me we must be exposed to the intimate details of our neighbors’ intimate conversations because “Collaboration!”  Don’t tell me being this close to employees singing and dancing (due to another employee playing Pharrell’s “Happy”) is because “Collaboration!”  It’s a flat-out lie.

Smaller walls = more information about what is going on around you = more distraction.  There’s a reason why conference rooms are usually enclosed by opaque walls: transparent walls are REALLY distracting!  Also, smaller walls = less sound absorption = more distraction and more noise!  Did you know that the human brain is more attuned to picking up human speech than any other sound?  Well, guess what?  If your company just moved you to an open workspace, they just made human speech audible from not 10 ft., not 20 ft., not even 30 ft. away, but from 40 ft. away and beyond now!  More distraction!

Somebody somewhere said “there’s going to be more noise and people are just going to have to deal with it.”  They also said, “it will sound better if we say we are a very collaborative group and need to be closer to each other!”  Which quote made it into the Employee Manual, do you think?  “You’ll be surprised by how quiet it actually is!”  Yeah, I’ve heard that one too.  The only time it is really quiet at my workplace is when everyone is attending an all-hands meeting, it is really early in the morning, or really late at night.  There can’t be any noise, because there are no people there to make noise!

It’s one thing to put up with noise at your local coffee shop: you have no investment in what people are talking about there.  But at work, every conversation around you may have juicy tidbits you may not hear otherwise (if everyone had an office, you know, like in the old days).  But here’s the catch: people don’t have serious conversations in an open workspace because they know everyone is listening.  So guess what?  Those “collaborative” conversations are increasingly being reduced to chit-chat, joking, and useless banter.  Can’t see how this can possibly hurt real work.

Blowing your nose?  Your colleague 50 ft. away can now hear it.  Coughing?  Sally at the west end of the building can now hear it (probably smell it as well, due to the lack of any wall taller than 3 ft. and drafty office space)  Moving around in a squeaky chair?  Trust me, every one within a quarter-mile is now getting annoyed by it.  Everyone is now forced to deal with every nuance, every last subtle utterance either you, your environment, or your colleagues make.  It doesn’t matter that you put up signs everywhere saying “Quiet Zone!”  No one sees them, no one reads them, and no one obeys them.

If you are in cubicle that is next to a building entrance, I feel even more for you, because everyone who goes by TALKS.  They figure since they are moving, the people they walk by will only have to deal with the noise for a little while.  Which is true…for just that particular person.  But imagine a hundred people walking by everyday with the same philosophy.  It piles up to become noise ALL DAY LONG.

I don’t know about you, but <sarcasm>I know I work at my peak when I have to work with e-mail notifications, meeting reminders, phone calls, unsolicited visits, across-the-room questions, toilets flushing, impromptu meetings at someone’s desk a few inches away, prairie dogs (people popping over cubicle walls), loud phone conversations, burnt popcorn smells, and people constantly walking by</sarcasm>.  On top of that, I’m expected to get work done.  Sounds like the perfect environment to foster real work.

I wish I could work for a company that uses library rules for its workspaces.  Next time you can’t seem to hear yourself think, go to a library, sit down, and observe the environment.  Everyone is focused, everyone is quiet, and those people who are talking are whispering.  Why?  Because reading comprehension requires NO NOISE and NO DISTRACTION.  Libraries have a fixed set of rules that have been in place since libraries were created.  You don’t talk in a library.  If you need to talk to someone else, you get a room and talk.  Otherwise, you are admonished with a “SSSHHHH!” from a scary librarian.  And people are conditioned to fear the “SSSHHHH” that librarians give since they went to grade school.

Imagine trying to follow a complex train of thought or a complicated set of instructions and having the toilet flush right next to you, or someone talking on a speakerphone.  You may find yourself re-reading things to make sure you got it right.  That’s more time wasted.  Why is it increasingly OK at work to have to deal with noise and distraction?  Don’t tell me it is in the name of collaboration.  It is in the name of SAVING MONEY.  Tell people to observe library rules in the workplace, and after they stop laughing, they ask you, “Wait, you’re serious?  This is not a library!”

Well maybe it should be.  If companies would hire scary librarians to keep things quiet in the modern-day workplace, I would work for them until I retire.  But until they do, I will be looking for another work-from-home job, where I can have four walls, minimal distractions, and if I want it, no NOISE.  Let the sales guys have their bullpens and employee moshpits where anything goes…there are software developers over here trying to get some real work done.

You may think I am anti-social, or that I am opposed to working with anyone.  I assure you that’s not true.  But being forced to work with people who are three feet away from me and constantly talking to others or constantly on the phone really gets on my nerves when I am trying to design database models or program application code.  Maybe I am too sensitive to distraction.  All I know is that I did better work when things were quieter, there was less light (another story entirely), and I could not see anyone else.  Just sayin’.